TOTM

Brazil Is Counting Votes Before Counting the Costs of Digital Regulation

Even as Brazil’s government is racing to find the votes for a sweeping digital-markets law, it’s still struggling to explain why the country needs it.

The Chamber of Deputies, Brazil’s lower house, is expected to vote tomorrow, Nov. 17, on Bill 4,675/2025. The bill would let the Administrative Council for Economic Defense (CADE), Brazil’s antitrust authority, designate digital platforms as “systemically relevant” and impose special obligations without first establishing an antitrust violation. For a closer look at the proposal (in Portuguese), I recommend my colleague Dario Oliveira Neto’s analysis on LinkedIn.

As Valor Econômico reported Nov. 13, the bill’s rapporteur, Aliel Machado—the lawmaker tasked with reviewing the proposal and recommending a text for the chamber to consider—has been courting centrist parties to secure passage. The government appears close enough to a majority to consider a vote, but whether it has one remains unclear. Negotiations today and tomorrow will determine whether the vote goes ahead.

The government has a clear political reason to move quickly, but hasn’t shown an economic reason to do the same. President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s administration wants to advance its legislative priorities before a more right-leaning Congress takes office in February. Chamber Speaker Hugo Motta decides which bills reach the floor, giving him considerable leverage as he seeks another term as speaker.

Scheduling a vote and winning it are separate questions, though bringing the bill to the floor would likely signal that its sponsors believe they have the votes. Even if it passes the chamber, it would face another round of debate in the Senate, where approval is far from assured.

Those calculations explain the rush, but don’t make the case for the policy. In July, the Brazilian Chamber of the Digital Economy warned that the proposal lacked published impact analyses measuring its costs and consequences. Supporters invoke foreign precedents, consumer protection, opportunities for smaller businesses, and platforms’ political influence. Each claim merits scrutiny, and none answers the central questions on its own: What competition problem requires these new powers, and why should Brazilians expect the benefits to exceed the costs?

Read the full piece here.


Back
to Top