TOTM

Deregulation by the Ton: The FRA’s Heavy Paperwork and Lightweight Relief

In November 1962, Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev addressed the Central Committee plenum to vent his frustration over the glaring distortions created by the state’s central economic planning. His chief complaint concerned a metric known as val—gross industrial output measured by weight or volume. Lighting factories faced production quotas based on sheer tonnage, rather than quality or consumer demand. Their response was rational, if disastrous.

“The chandeliers grew heavier and heavier until they started pulling ceilings down,” Khrushchev noted. “The workers fulfilled the plan… but who needs this plan? To whom does it give light?”

As economists have since pointed out, this illustrates Goodhart’s law: When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. Central planning rewards producers for hitting numerical targets, even when doing so wastes resources and destroys economic value.

Decades later, the Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) appears to have adopted the Soviet lighting industry’s approach. Under pressure from executive mandates to deliver a high volume of deregulation, the FRA recently touted a record of 65 deregulatory actions finalized between January 2025 and late 2026.

On paper, that’s a staggering amount of regulatory relief. In practice, the FRA has simply manufactured heavy, low-value chandeliers.

Read the full piece here.


Back
to Top