‘Contemporary Law and Economics,’ by Adam Chilton, Joshua C. Macey & Mila Versteeg
What does it mean to be a law & economics (L&E) scholar? It can’t require a Ph.D. in economics. Richard Posner doesn’t have one. He didn’t even major in economics as an undergraduate, preferring English—as did his Chicago colleagues Douglas Baird and Diane Wood. It can’t require a law degree, either, or Ronald Coase, William Landes, and many other leading lights are out.
Perhaps it’s a focus on rational actors—people making choices to advance their interests—and wealth maximization? But that would leave out the behavioral movement, which examines departures from rational decision-making. A field for empirical work—research based on observation and data? That would also leave out many of its founders. OK, then. Perhaps the L&E tent is now so big that it’s undefinable. No particular expertise is required, nor any shared precepts.
In “Contemporary Law and Economics,” Adam Chilton, Joshua Macey, and Mila Versteeg disagree. L&E is still a cohesive field. Writing for the University of Chicago Law Review’s 2025 symposium, the authors acknowledge that L&E’s contours shift. Its scholars don’t all agree on its definition—an unsurprising result for a diverse field of study. But distinct qualities still set L&E apart from other scholarship, including work influenced by economics.
As newer groups such as the Law and Political Economy (LPE) movement capture scholarly attention, our authors set out to tell us what L&E is, given that approaches as diverse as empirical legal studies, welfarism (evaluating rules by their effects on human well-being), and rational choice all claim to be within its ambit.